A Comprehensive Look at the EU Commission’s Proposed SEP Regulation

August 3, 2023


We delve into the latest developments concerning the European Commission’s draft regulation on Standard Essential Patents (SEPs). The EU Commission has recognized the significance of SEPs in promoting innovation, competition, and fair licensing practices. With the rapid evolution of technology, the need for an effective and well-defined regulatory framework has become apparent. Let’s explore the key aspects and potential implications of this proposed SEP regulation.


Defining Standard Essential Patents (SEPs)

Standard Essential Patents refer to intellectual property rights that are indispensable to implement a specific technological standard. These patents are crucial for ensuring interoperability and compatibility among various products and services across industries. Given their importance, SEP holders are obliged to grant licenses to interested parties on Fair, Reasonable, and Non-Discriminatory (FRAND) terms.


The Objectives of the Proposed Regulation

The primary objectives of the EU Commission’s proposed SEP regulation are as follows:

  1. Ensuring Fair and Predictable Licensing: The regulation aims to establish a clear and predictable licensing framework for SEPs, promoting fair access to essential technologies.
  2. Preventing Patent Holdup and Holdout: Patent holdup occurs when SEP holders abuse their market power by demanding excessive licensing fees. Conversely, patent holdout refers to implementers delaying or refusing to take a license at reasonable terms. The regulation seeks to address both issues and maintain a balanced patent licensing environment.
  3. Enhancing Dispute Resolution: The proposed framework aims to streamline dispute resolution mechanisms between SEP holders and implementers, fostering efficient and timely solutions.
  4. Fostering Innovation and Market Competitiveness: By ensuring equitable access to essential technologies, the regulation aims to stimulate innovation and competition within the EU market.

Key Provisions of the Regulation

  1. Transparency and Information Disclosure: The regulation requires SEP holders to provide clear and accessible information about their patents, licensing terms, and related agreements. This step intends to enhance transparency and enable potential licensees to make informed decisions.
  2. FRAND Assessment: A consistent and transparent methodology for assessing FRAND terms will be established. This will help in resolving disputes related to fair licensing, ensuring that both parties are treated fairly.
  3. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Mechanism: The regulation will encourage the use of Alternative Dispute Resolution mechanisms to facilitate quick and efficient resolution of SEP-related conflicts.
  4. Injunctions and Portfolio Licensing: The regulation addresses the issue of injunctive relief, ensuring that SEP holders cannot seek injunctions against willing licensees. Additionally, concerns related to portfolio licensing, where an SEP holder bundles essential and non-essential patents together, will also be addressed.
  5. Essentiality Declarations: The proposed regulation requires improved scrutiny of essentiality declarations, ensuring that only truly essential patents are designated as such.

Leave a Comment